Rustic Boiled Potatoes with Lemon, Dill, and Anchovy Butter

These rustic boiled potatoes with lemon, dill, and anchovy butter are simple yet deeply flavourful. Soft starchy potatoes absorb the savoury anchovy butter beautifully, while fresh dill and lemon zest keep the dish bright and spring-like. This rustic potato side dish is comforting, buttery, and perfect for grilling season or casual spring dinners.

Jump to Recipe

Hey, folks – I hope you all are doing well! As the weather slowly gets warmer, I always start craving simpler side dishes that still feel comforting and full of flavour. These rustic boiled potatoes are exactly that kind of recipe – humble ingredients transformed into something rich, savoury, and surprisingly elegant with very little effort. So, let’s dive into these Rustic Boiled Potatoes with Lemon, Dill, and Anchovy Butter.

Why You’ll Love These Rustic Boiled Potatoes with with Lemon, Dill, and Anchovy

• Rustic and comforting. Unlike classic structured potato salads, these boiled potatoes intentionally embrace a softer, more rustic texture.
• Full of flavour. Anchovy butter adds deep savoury richness without making the dish taste overly fishy.
• Perfect for spring and grilling season. These rustic boiled potatoes pair beautifully with grilled meats, fish, or fresh vegetable salads.
• Bright yet buttery. Lemon zest and fresh dill balance the richness and keep the dish feeling fresh.
• Easy to customize. You can add radishes, green onions, capers, jammy eggs, or even asparagus.
• Delicious warm or at room temperature. That makes this rustic potato side dish ideal for gatherings and casual entertaining.

Flavour and Texture Profile

These rustic boiled potatoes with anchovy butter are rich, savoury, buttery, and herbaceous. The anchovy flavour melts into the potatoes rather than dominating them, creating a subtle umami depth throughout the dish.

Because starchy potatoes are used intentionally, some of the potatoes gently break apart as they are tossed with the warm dressing. Instead of looking perfectly neat and structured, the potatoes develop little creamy “islands” that combine with the melted anchovy butter and olive oil. The result is deeply comforting and flavourful.

Fresh dill and lemon zest brighten the entire dish and help balance the buttery richness. Overall, the flavour profile feels rustic, cozy, and slightly European-inspired.

Why Anchovy Butter Works So Well with Potatoes

Anchovy butter and potatoes are a perfect combination because the warm potatoes absorb the savoury butter exceptionally well. The anchovies melt into the butter and create a deep umami flavour that enhances the potatoes without overpowering them.

For this recipe, I also added a small knob of homemade anchovy compound butter directly to the hot potatoes for additional richness and flavour. If you already have anchovy butter prepared, this rustic potato side dish becomes even easier to make.

Ingredients You’ll Need for These Boiled Potatoes with Anchovy Butter and Dill

It’s easy to make these rustic boiled potatoes with anchovy butter using a handful of simple yet flavourful ingredients.

• Starchy potatoes: I intentionally used starchy potatoes here because they absorb the buttery anchovy dressing beautifully. Some pieces naturally break apart slightly, creating creamy rustic pockets throughout the dish.
• Anchovies: A few anchovy fillets are gently melted into olive oil for the base of the dressing, while additional finely minced anchovies add more savoury depth and texture at the end.
• Homemade anchovy butter: A small knob of anchovy compound butter melts directly into the hot potatoes, adding richness, saltiness, and an extra layer of flavour.
• Olive oil: Just a little olive oil helps the anchovies melt smoothly and evenly coat the potatoes.
• Fresh dill: Dill keeps the dish fresh, herbaceous, and distinctly spring-like.
• Lemon zest: Bright lemon zest balances the buttery richness and helps lighten the overall flavour profile.
• Salt and black pepper: Simple seasonings are all you need to finish the dish.

Possible Additions and Variations

Although these rustic boiled potatoes are already delicious, you can easily adapt the recipe depending on the season or what you have available.

• Jammy eggs: Add soft or jammy eggs to turn the potatoes into a more substantial lunch or light dinner.
• Fresh vegetables: Radishes, green onions, or lightly blanched asparagus work especially well in spring.
• Capers: A spoonful of capers adds additional briny sharpness that complements the anchovies beautifully.
• Fresh herbs: Although dill is my favourite here, parsley or chives also work nicely.
• Sour cream: A spoonful of sour cream adds gentle tanginess and creates a more comforting Eastern European-style flavour profile.
• Crispy breadcrumbs: For extra texture, finish the potatoes with toasted buttery breadcrumbs.

Why Starchy Potatoes Work Best in This Recipe

Many warm potato salads and potato side dishes rely on waxy potatoes because they hold their shape neatly. However, for this rustic boiled potato recipe, I intentionally chose starchy potatoes instead.

Starchy potatoes absorb the anchovy butter and olive oil exceptionally well. As they soften, some pieces naturally break apart and create creamy pockets throughout the dish, helping the buttery dressing coat the potatoes more evenly.

Waxy potatoes, such as red potatoes or baby potatoes, would create a cleaner and firmer result. They are excellent for classic potato salads where presentation and structure are more important. However, they do not absorb flavour quite as deeply in this specific recipe.

Ultimately, both styles work, but the choice depends on the result you want:

• For a cleaner, firmer texture, choose waxy potatoes.
• For rustic, buttery comfort with richer flavour absorption, starchy potatoes work beautifully.

How to Make Rustic Boiled Potatoes with Dill and Anchovy Butter

Making these rustic boiled potatoes with dill and anchovy butter is wonderfully simple.

Start by boiling the potatoes in salted water until tender. Because starchy potatoes are intentionally used here, some pieces may naturally begin to break apart – that’s part of the rustic charm of the dish.

Meanwhile, gently melt a couple of anchovy fillets in a little olive oil. Once the potatoes are drained and still hot, toss them carefully with the warm anchovy oil and a small knob of homemade anchovy butter.

Finish the dish with finely minced anchovies, fresh dill, lemon zest, black pepper, and additional salt if needed. The potatoes absorb the buttery anchovy flavour best while still warm, so serve immediately or slightly warm for the best texture and flavour.

What to Serve with Rustic Boiled Potatoes

These rustic boiled potatoes with dill and anchovy butter pair beautifully with simple spring and summer dishes.

They work especially well alongside:

• grilled chicken.
• grilled fish or salmon.
• sausages.
• smoked fish.
• roasted vegetables.

I also particularly like serving these lemon dill boiled potatoes a simple fresh vegetable salad made with tomatoes, cucumbers, radishes, dill, and green onions, dressed lightly with sour cream. The cool freshness of the salad contrasts beautifully with the warm buttery potatoes.

More Potato Side Dishes and Spring Recipes

Are you looking for more fun recipes, like these Rustic Boiled Potatoes with Lemon, Dill, and Anchovy Butter? Be sure to check more recipes below:

• Creamy Potato Salad: A rich but not-too-heavy potato salad with ricotta, Parmesan, olive oil, garlic, onions, herbs, and smoked paprika.
• Potato Salad with Chives: A lighter potato salad with chives, parsley, shallot, olive oil, balsamic vinegar, and optional maple syrup.
• Pesto Potato Salad: A creamy pesto potato salad with arugula, Parmesan, pine nuts, and basil – excellent for grilling season.
• Smoked Salmon Potato Salad: A fresh and elegant potato salad with smoked salmon, herbs, and bright spring flavours.
• Anchovy Deviled Eggs: A refined anchovy appetizer with sour cream, dill, and lemon zest that naturally echoes the dill-and-anchovy flavour profile here.
• Lavender Roasted Potatoes: Crispy roasted potatoes infused with lavender for an elegant and aromatic side dish perfect for spring and summer meals.

I’d love for you to try these rustic boiled potatoes with lemon, dill, and anchovy butter. If you give it a go, please share your results in the comments, message me on Instagram, or post your photos with the hashtag #havocinthekitchen. I look forward to seeing your creations and hearing your thoughts.

Cheers!